Book Review: Durbin (Binoculars)
As an avid school-going reader, my interest always centred around the weekly magazines we subscribed to at home. Other than the usual ones for kids, the curious cat inside me sometimes secretly dared to go through the ones meant for elders. Like the literary magazine, Desh. At that time, I was surprised to find that the same authors whose works for children I was hooked to, like Sunil Gangopadhyay, Samaresh Basu and Shirshendu Mukhopadhyay, were writing for the elders too. One such serial novella, Durbin, was first published in Desh magazine. Recently, I had a chance to read the book, and today, I have decided to write about it.
About the Author
Shirshendu Mukhopadhyay is one of the most prominent literary figures of our times whose vast contribution to Bengali literature is unparalleled. He has been awarded many times for his outstanding works in adult and children's literature. His notable works include Kagojer Bou, Chokh, and Chhayamoyi for adults, Nabiganjer Doittyo, Patalghar, and various paranormal and ghost stories.
About the Book
The name Durbin means Binoculars. The story spans three generations of a wealthy landlord family. It starts with Hemkanta, an honest widower who is soft-spoken and kind-hearted, indifferent towards the condition of his vast estate, who was an eye-witness to India's struggle for independence, and indirectly gets involved in it by offering shelter to one of the revolutionaries of that time. The next focus of the story falls on Krishnakanta, one of Hemkanta's sons, who maintains a daring demeanour and gets actively involved in India's freedom movement. The final focus is on Dhrubo, a drunkard who often comes across as indifferent, irresponsible, and a strong opponent of his father's (now politician Krishnakanta) political ideologies.
The Story & Characters
The character of Hemkanta is very simple, a widower who finds joy in simple things in life and, after spending a very unhappening life, gets romantically involved with a widow, Rangabati, in his later years, much as a need to provide strong support for his ailing health and mental weakness, then his physical desire. While Krishnakanta, who is very different from his father, places his love for his country over anything else, he goes through the ordeals of the tough British treatment as a freedom fighter, only to rise as an able and strong political leader in his later years, finally taking oath as a cabinet minister. He is a man of strength and will, who most people look up to, but on the personal front, his estranged relationship with his wife leads her to commit suicide, leaving his son, Dhrubo, to turn into his strongest hater. The most flawed character, Seem Dhrubo, was a witness to his mother's horrific death and considers his father's negligence towards her as the main reason. To keep his grief concealed, he seeks solace in alcohol and in the company of pretty women. His mood swings and daily banter is unchanged even after his marriage. However, when he becomes a father, everyone starts noticing the slow but significant progress in his life. The once brute and irresponsible brat takes charge of his life. The story ends on a tragic note, shifting his lifelong hatred towards his father to empathy and respect.
My Review
The book consists of a whopping 600+ pages. I loved how the author highlighted the complexities of all characters, never demonising any of them. Even Dhrubo, the one character who comes across as the most reckless, becomes a caring husband in times of need. Despite being a charmer often seen around women, he neither objectifies nor takes undue advantage of their trust. Krishnakanta, a strong and powerful, highly successful politician, failed to be a good husband and father. The last few pages reveal the vulnerable sides of both Krishnakanta and Dhrubo, including their hidden dilemma and inhibitions of coming close to each other for all these years. Even Hemkanta- a man of few words who often came across as a weak individual, secretly wants to die every time he thinks about his inability to protect the freedom fighter who he had given refuge to but could not save from the British punishment. The characters, layered under various complicated incidents and activities, stand out with their individual virtue. And that is the beauty of this book. There are many side characters who one would love to hate, but every mean act is well-explained with suitable reasoning that comes through the subtle building up of their activities. The author, indeed, has a deep observational approach to the complexities of the human psyche that turns every character into a real human, with their individual insecurities and weaknesses, virtue and vices.
This blog post is part of ‘Blogaberry Dazzle’
hosted by Cindy D’Silva and Noor Anand Chawla.
I just read your review of "Durbin (Binoculars)" on your blog, and it truly piqued my interest. Your insights into the novel's exploration of perspective and observation were enlightening. I was particularly intrigued by your analysis of the protagonist's journey and how the binoculars symbolized his desire to see beyond the surface of his surroundings. Your thoughtful critique of the author's narrative style and character development provided a deeper understanding of the book's themes. I also appreciated your mention of the cultural nuances that enriched the story, offering readers a glimpse into a different world. Your review has definitely added "Durbin" to my reading list. Thank you for sharing such a comprehensive and engaging review!
ReplyDeleteThanks for reading
DeleteThis was such an engaging review! I loved how you highlighted the depth of each character and their complexities without making anyone purely good or evil. Now I’m really curious to read Durbin and experience this journey across generations myself.
ReplyDeleteGlad you liked
DeleteYour book review of "Durbin" was my first encounter with a work from Shirshendu Mukhopadhyay and I am quite impressed with it.Three generations would need 600 pages at least.
ReplyDeleteThe plot and characters are quite intricate and well developed with a string emotional appeal for me.How the book gets it title might be interesting, maybe it comes from how we assess people from afar and how it changes when we come closer to them!
True that its a close look at the flawed characters
DeleteSpanning three generations and set during the freedom struggle, this book seems quite an interesting read. Dhrubo with his flaws is a character I would love to explore.
ReplyDeleteYes, a characters with lot of shades
DeleteThis seems very interesting. I love the plot of it. Will make sure that this to be my next read after the pile of books that i already have
ReplyDeleteGlad to know
DeleteI first read the title in English, then as I scrolled, it became clear that it was 'door' 'been'. Then, it struck me how the author would have viewed his plot, bringing the things that were far, closer and bigger. Capturing three generations is tough. Does sound like a good read.
ReplyDeleteYes, an in-depth view of the characters
DeleteI liked how you highlighted the depth of each character, from Hemkanta's simplicity to Krishnakanta's patriotism and Dhrubo's transformation. I was almost sold then I read 600+ pages and went, "Okay, not for me!" I will keep it mind for when I'm ready to pick up thick books :D
ReplyDeleteHaha, trust me I had my inhibitions too
DeleteThe title sounds fascinating. We can see faraway things as close through a Durbin. Your review highlights the main characters. Writing about three generations is surely a massive task. I am struggling to write 2500 words for the anthology. Will check out the book for sure.
ReplyDeleteIKR! I haven't even started with an idea for the anthology
DeleteDurbin the title is intresting. I love the way you described each character in depth. This is from the time of Revolution then must be fascinating. 600 + pages oh my god.. I can't read such big book. I like your review.
ReplyDeleteYes, its often challenging to read 600+ pages
DeleteThat sounds like a fascinating read! A story spanning three generations, delving into their myriad emotions and transformations, is truly an impressive feat. Would love to get my hands on it!
ReplyDeleteGlad you liked
DeleteDespite the daunting 600 pages, the premise seems very intriguing. Such literary prose shouldn't be just read. They should be savoured, every character's persona read, analyzed, loved or hated, and when doing so, you become part of the story which stays with you for life. Hoping to find an English translation that I will savour slowly. Thanks for the recco.
ReplyDeleteI did not find any English translation of this book. However, his other work, The Aunt Who Wouldn't Die is an English translation
Delete600 pages is quite massive, but I'm sure the book was interesting enouh to you hooked till the end.
ReplyDeleteIt is
DeleteTotally piqued by your review. Such nuances in character and as we all say people are not black and white but have shades. Lovely review .
ReplyDeleteThanks for liking
DeleteBengal is one of the regions in India which boasts a vast and strong literary legacy! I kind of feel jealous who can enjoy those fabulous works done by these master storytellers from Bengal. Durbin looks really interesting from what you have told us about it. Are there any translations available of this one, in English or in Marathi?
ReplyDeleteThis particular book has not been translated but one of his popular books, The Aunt Who Wouldn't Die is an interesting read
DeleteI love how you’ve captured the depth of Durbin! The layered characters, their flaws, and emotional growth make it sound like an intense yet beautiful read. Your review reflects a deep appreciation for Mukhopadhyay’s storytelling—now I’m tempted to pick it up!
ReplyDeleteGlad you liked it
DeleteSounds like a beautiful story. I love inter-generational stories like the trilogy by ashapoorna devi or glass palace by amitav ghosh.
ReplyDeleteThose are powerful stories
DeleteI love how this review captures the depth of each character, making them feel so real and relatable. The way their flaws and strengths intertwine adds a beautiful complexity to the story!
ReplyDeleteThanks for liking
DeleteMy mom is a big fan of Shirshendu Mukhopadhyay and I am ashamed to admit that I am yet to read his work. Going through your review has definitely motivated me!
ReplyDeleteGlad it did so
DeleteThis review makes Durbin sound so interesting, I love stories where no one is completely good or bad, just human. And even though the book is 600+ pages, it sounds like it’s worth reading. You explained everything so well—now I really want to read it.
ReplyDelete-Anjali (messymom)
Glad you liked
DeleteThis is quite an interesting plot. Thanks for sharing your review will check this out soon
ReplyDelete